PLANS to transform Shelley Manor were turned down by councillors on Monday, August 15 despite impassioned pleas from colleagues and residents.

Ten members of Bournemouth Borough Council's planning board supported a recommendation to reject the scheme for a six-storey building incorporating a medical centre, 14 flats, theatre, museum and caf with one member voting against.

Planning officer Eleanor Bispham described the proposed building as "bulky" and said it would harm the character of a listed building and conversation area, affect trees and cause congestion.

But Pat Clark, chairman of the Friends of Shelley Park, said the project was "the best possible option for the site".

Representing residents, Tony Ruth said: "The residents support what is planned and approve the removal of the unsightly buildings on the east side."

Backing the scheme, Steven Humphrey stressed the need for accommodation for local artists, saying: "If you can encourage artists to stay in Boscombe you will regenerate the area."

Ward councillors spoke vehemently in favour of the proposals, urging members to ignore the officers' recommendation.

Councillor Phil Stanley-Watts said: "Shelley Manor could be a community focal point. Without the developers' help this building will fall into decay and rot."

Councillor Mike Everingham said the scheme was "desperately needed" while Councillor Andrew Garratt said: "Bringing Shelley Manor back into use as a living building will more than outweigh any concerns about its architectural merits."

Moving the officers' recommendation, Councillor Roger West said: "I think it is an exciting proposal but there are still some issues to be resolved."

Seconding the proposal, Councillor John Beesley said: "The scale of the building will dominate the site. The manor will be compromised. English Heritage has told us to refuse the application."

Councillor David Smith said he could understand councillors' and residents' frustrations but warned: "It is easy to get carried away with the emotion and grasp the first thing that comes along."

Chairman Councillor Ken Mantock said: "It is crystal clear that this scheme is totally out of character with a listed building and conservation area. It does not comply with our planning policies. It may be an unpopular decision but it is the only proper and right decision."

First published: August 17, 2005