A WEST BAY couple have begun demolishing a £50,000 extension they built without getting planning permission.
Edward Durnin and his wife Anita watched in dismay as their ‘beautiful’ granny annexe at 17, West Walk, turned to rubble – vowing to quit the estate.
The couple insist they carried out the garage conversion at their hillside bungalow unaware they needed change of use consent.
The work was almost completed when residents complained to council planners.
An appeal to retain the building was lost and West Dorset District Council issued an enforcement notice requiring the extension to be demolished by July.
Beaminster builder Martin Sibley is now pulling down the extension he took months to build.
Retired hotelier Mr Durnin, 72, said: “We thought about taking our case to the High Court but we could not afford the costs if we lost – we paid £50,000 to build the extension and it’s another £10,000 now to knock it down.
“Right from the start we had the building control people here while we converted the double garage – they visited us time and again – but we didn’t realise they were a separate entity from the planning people.”
Mr Durnin said they only found out they needed change of use permission after near neighbours called the authorities to complain.
“All this has cost us a terrible amount of money.
“Why did no one stop us before we had finished the building? It was only change of use and in our ignorance we thought building control was enough.
“The authorities went right over the top.”
Mrs Durnin, 70, said: “We think the annexe improved the estate. It was beautiful with its bay window.
“We wanted it because we were looking to the future.
“Instead of relying on the state to look after us we planned to move in there and let one of the children have the main house.”
Now the couple say they are so disgusted by their treatment they plan to sell up.
Mr Durnin said: “We plan to move off the estate although we won’t be leaving the area as our daughter lives here.”
Builder Mr Sibley said: “I’m obviously upset at having to pull down my own work.
“I thought it was ideal as a starter home or apartment – something the Government is crying out for.
“When the buildings officer came following the complaints he told me to carry on with the extension – we feel he should have stopped us.”
Malcolm Leighton, a member of the West Cliff Houseowners Association and a former chairman, said: “Hopefully, now the garage is being put back we will all live happily ever after.”
Retired builder Mr Leighton said he and fellow resident Chris Cherry had complained to the planning authorities about the unauthorised extension.
He stressed: “The residents’ association had nothing to do with this as a group. It is not in their remit to get involved in planning.
“It was just individuals deciding to talk to each other as they have a right to do.
“I went to the council offices at Mountfield and did a search and discovered they did not have planning consent.
“There have been so many bits and bobs added to this property over the years so Mr Cherry and I decided he was not going to get away with this without a fight.
“If he had co-operated with the council to begin with he might have ended up with something very similar to that what he had to pull down.
“We all feel it’s a tragic waste of material and labour.”
Mr Cherry, a former deputy chairman of the homeowners’ association, said: “If he had played by the rules I don’t think there would have been such a hoo-hah.”
West Dorset Council’s Development Services team leader Simon Ludgate said: “Mr Durnin mistakenly did not seek planning permission for his extension and applied for retrospective permission which was refused by Government inspectors.
“We have since worked with Mr Durnin to achieve planning permission to restore the building to what it was originally.
“While we sympathise with Mr Durnin, planning rules have to be observed to protect West Dorset and if people have any doubt they should get in touch with us before work starts as we are happy to advise.”
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereLast Updated:
Report this comment Cancel